Homes for Sale
Sanibel & Captiva - Fort Myers FL & The Beaches
Test drive our new site here! We are excited to share this new site with you during our testing period.
VIEW ALL PRICE REDUCTIONS: Updated hourly, view real time price changes for all southwest FL homes for sale. Pfeifer Realty displays all price reductions on real estate for sale on Sanibel FL, Cape Coral, Captiva, Fort Myers, Ft. Myers Beach FL, and Southwest Florida. Search and find your FL home on Sanibel, Captiva, Fort Myers or Fort Myers Beach. Pfeifer Realty Group - your real estate home team.

JUST LISTED PROPERTIES: search all homes for sale and just listed condos, view newest listings of commercial real estate. Sanibel FL - Captiva FL - Fort Myers FL - Cape Coral - Ft. Myers Beach.

  • "He and his team helped us to navigate the entire selling process and provided referrals to legal assistance and title contacts which made the entire transaction go very smoothly. From start to finish, it took less than 90 days from the representation of our property to our settlement date." Ray Hansell
  • "Everyone at Pfeifer Realty Group was helpful, courteous and professional. Eric's strengths include his marketing skills and perserverance." The Boyle Family Sanibel, Florida
  • "Everyone at Pfeifer Realty Group was always helpful and knowledgeable. My purchase had many complications which they helped me through. I would definitely recommend them. I was originally working with someone else and Eric gladly helped. Eric's strengths include enthusiasm, energy level, knowledge and desire to learn."K. Mahar, Sanibel Island
  • "Everyone at Pfeifer Realty Group was very helpful, pleasant and went out of their way to heop when needed before and after our purchase. After looking at listings online, iut appeared that Eric had some of the best listings in Sanibel. Eric Pfeifer is prompt, patient, helpful, knowledable and easy to be around. We had a great experience, bought a house and are looking forward to our future on Sanibel Island." The Allen Family, Lansdale, PA
  • In our opinion Pfeifer Reality Group is simply the BEST! We put quite a bit of work into researching Realtors to help us find and purchase a Sanibel property. While we zoned in on a few great ones, we selected Eric Pfeifer due to both his outstanding reviews/references but esp he really stood out when we interviewed him w/exceptional knowledge of the local market, excellent examples and listening skills, and just clearly really sharp and on top of his game. C. Schulz, Sanibel Island & Northbrook, IL
  • "Our overall experience with Eric and Pfeifer Realty Group was excellent. Eric is knowledgable about the island, a good communicator, and patient." The Ponader Family, Sanibel Island, Florida & Indianapolis, Indiana
  • "All members of the Pfeifer Realty Group team were helpful. You people are above board and honest, it shows" J. Stegmeier, Grand Rapids, MI
  • "We were referred to Eric by an island resident and found him to be a great communicator who can simplify difficult problems. We are extremely happy with Eric Pfeifer and his ability to get everything completed. Our overall experience with Pfeifer Realty Group was great." The Hughes Family, Red Wing, MN
  • "Eric was recommended to us by another Sanibel resident who knew him. We had heard him speak at our Shell Harbor Home Owners Association Meeting. Eric is a really hard worker and I even got use to his red headed termperment, and sense of humor!!. The entire staff at Pfeifer Realty Group was wonderful and the process of selling our home was a very good exerience because of all of them." The Roccia Family St. Louis, MO
  • "I didn't know Eric when I was ready to list my property and he was highly recommended by a friend and very well known Sanibel resident. Eric has great communication skills and he gave me feed back on each showing which was very important to me. He has a great ability to explain the market and it's impact on my property sale. He is ethical, and was very patient. I would use Eric Pfeifer again and am proud to recommend Pfeifer Realty Group." M. Reilly, Sanibel, FL & Gulf Harbour Fort Myers
  • "Eric was recommended by a friend on Sanibel who is also a Sanibel Island Gulf Front condominium property manager. After trying for several years to sell our condo in a very bad real estate market, finding Eric and having him work hard on our behalf it was wonderful to have him find a buyer even though it wasn't easy in today's market. Eric worked hard and had good suggestions for us for sellling our property. He made every effort to find the buyer and then worked hard keeping us up to date on the progress of the purchase."B. Wayne & H Pels, Albany, NY & Sanibel Island, FL
  • "Eric's responsiveness, knowledge of the sanibel real estate market and properties for sale, as well as his non-pressuring approach make for an effective combination of strengths. We would recommend Eric and Pfeifer Realty Group to friends and use them again if the occasion arose" The Steinberg Family, Guilford, CT & Captiva Island FL
  • "After reviewing the the top 10, we chose to work with Eric Pfeifer. Pfeifer Realty Group's staff is excellent, responsive and knowledgeable."The Kursel Family Brookfield, WI

Why Choose Us

This locally owned & operated Sanibel real estate Brokerage sets the curve for dynamic marketing. Free from corporate delays, they rapidly activate innovative technology that benefits their clients. Hire a Pfeifer Realtor & you hire a team. Pfeifer's creative marketing & team approach result in listings that sell faster & agents that close more transactions. Their marketing team & Realtors work together: planning, promoting, brainstorming & scheduling to accomplish their client's goals.
Learn why our listings sell faster.
Pfeifer's team of real estate experts come from all areas of the country with college degrees in Biochemistry, Business, Education, Hospitality Biology & Engineering from Vanderbilt, Cornell, UCF and more. They share a common team-minded philosophy, working together to help clients achieve their goals. Integrity, community service, leadership, expertise, and customer service define this locally owned real estate brokerage.
Learn more about this real estate team...
As a 7 time recipient of the Annual Sanibel Captiva Community Service Award and the 2016's Sanibel Citizen of the Year, Broker-Owner Eric Pfeifer sets the tone for this locally owned Sanibel Island Brokerage. His strong work ethic, family values, faith, community service, and honest approach form the backbone of this Real Estate Sales Office. Measuring success one family at a time, Eric helps clients find the right property that suits their needs, budget, and their time frame. "I love what I do and am honored to represent my clients before, during and especially after any sale" ~ Eric
Learn More About Eric Pfeifer
From April 2008 to October 2020, Pfeifer Realty Group has donated $160,000 in non-profit support! Named Sanibel and Captiva Island's Citizen of the Year by the Chamber of Commerce for his commitment to the community, and having won the Sanibel Captiva Community Service Award 7 different years, Broker-Owner Eric Pfeifer sets the tone for a team of agents who are dedicated to supporting Sanibel & Captiva residents, visitors & the natural environment thru non-profit support. In 2013, Eric Formed Serving Sanibel LLC, the charitable arm of Pfeifer Realty to actively support local non profits. Pfeifer Realty has donated thousands of dollars with their on-going "give back" donation campaigns. Together with 7-time Emmy Award Winning Filmmaker David E. Carter, Pfeifer Realty Group produced 5 documentaries preserving island history that alone generated more than $35,000 in community support.
Our Community Service
Our email newsletter is a benchmark for buyers and sellers as a trusted resource for Sanibel, Captiva and Southwest Florida real estate news. Locals & visitors depend on our email updates for unbiased news on market activity. We provide property sales prices, days on market, price reductions, all new listings and pending sales activity. Our newsletter also provides relevant event news and lifestyle information with easy links to property types and communities that feature specific amenities. Real estate in our area is more than bricks and mortar, it's a complete lifestyle. Join our newsletter and make the tropical island lifestyle your future.
Join Our Newsletter