Loggerhead Cay on Sanibel Island

Loggerhead Cay is a Gulf-front condominium community on Sanibel Island’s East End featuring 168 two-bedroom residences, direct beach access, resort-style amenities, and convenient proximity to the Sanibel Causeway, Periwinkle Way shopping and dining, and Lighthouse Beach. The community is one of the island’s most popular weekly-rental destinations, attracting seasonal residents, vacation homeowners, and investors seeking beachfront property on Sanibel Island.

Located directly on the Gulf of Mexico, Loggerhead Cay offers a blend of beachfront living, rental flexibility, and community amenities that support both personal enjoyment and vacation-rental potential.

Community Facts & Features

• 🏡 Community Type: Gulf-front condominium community

• 🏘️ Total Units: 168 residences

• 🛏️ Typical Floor Plans: 2-bedroom / 2-bath condominiums

• 🌊 Location: Direct Gulf-front on Sanibel Island East End

• 🏖️ Beach Access: Direct access to Sanibel’s Gulf beaches

• 🏊 Large heated swimming pool

• 🎾 Tennis and pickleball courts

• 🏛️ Clubhouse and gathering areas

• 🔥 Grill and picnic areas

• 🐚 Shell washing stations and bike storage areas

• 🛗 Elevator access in buildings

• 📅 Minimum Rental Period: 7 days

• 🐾 Pet Policy: Limited pets allowed in some units (restrictions apply)

• 📍 Latitude / Longitude: 26.4429, -82.0443 (approximate complex location)

Community History

Loggerhead Cay was developed as one of Sanibel Island’s larger beachfront condominium communities, designed to provide direct Gulf access along with amenities that support vacation living and seasonal residency. The complex’s East End location has long made it popular with visitors and homeowners who want convenient access on and off the island while still enjoying beachfront living.

The community’s name reflects Sanibel’s connection to coastal wildlife, particularly the loggerhead sea turtles that nest on local beaches each year.

Community Overview

Loggerhead Cay consists of individually owned two-bedroom condominiums arranged around landscaped courtyards with pathways leading directly to the Gulf beach. Many residences feature screened lanais, updated kitchens, and Gulf or courtyard views.

The complex is known for its spacious layout, walkable grounds, and beachfront positioning. The combination of elevators, community amenities, and beach access makes Loggerhead Cay appealing to a wide range of buyers, including seasonal residents and vacation-rental investors.

Its East End location provides easy access to the Sanibel Causeway, Lighthouse Beach, and the shops and restaurants along Periwinkle Way.

Loggerhead Cay Residents Enjoy

Residents and guests enjoy a relaxed beachfront lifestyle centered around the Gulf of Mexico. The large heated pool, tennis and pickleball courts, grilling areas, and clubhouse spaces create a resort-like environment while maintaining the comfort of a residential community.

Direct beach access makes shelling, swimming, and sunset viewing part of everyday life at Loggerhead Cay.

Enjoy watching local artist Rachael Pierce create one of several murals designed to engage visitors with an interactive scavenger hunt at Loggerhead Cay. View Rachael Painting Turtle Murals Here.

Minutes To Nearby Destinations

Loggerhead Cay offers convenient access to island destinations:

⏱ 3–5 minutes to the Sanibel Causeway
⏱ 5 minutes to Lighthouse Beach
⏱ 5 minutes to Periwinkle Way shopping and dining
⏱ 10 minutes to the Sanibel Golf Club
⏱ 35–40 minutes to Southwest Florida International Airport

(Drive times are approximate and may vary by traffic and season.)

Buying in Loggerhead Cay

For buyers, Loggerhead Cay offers a rare opportunity to own Gulf-front property on Sanibel Island with weekly rental capability. The combination of beachfront location, established rental demand, and community amenities makes the complex attractive to both personal-use buyers and investors.

Units with Gulf views, updated interiors, and strong rental history often generate the highest buyer interest.

Selling in Loggerhead Cay

For sellers, Loggerhead Cay’s value is driven by its direct Gulf-front location, weekly rental flexibility, East End accessibility, and established reputation as a vacation-rental community. Highlighting Gulf views, rental performance, and recent renovations can help listings stand out.

The community’s scale and beachfront positioning continue to attract buyers seeking Sanibel condominium ownership.

Explore Homes in Loggerhead Cay

View Loggerhead Cay Homes for Sale Below

Interested in buying or selling in Loggerhead Cay? Our local experts are here to help.

👉 Request a Private Showing
👉 Ask a Local Expert
👉 Contact Us for Current HOA Fees, Association Documents, & Property Taxes